Skip to content
calendar icon | 15 min read

How to manage an underperforming employee: a detailed guide

How to Manage an Underperforming Employee: A detailed Guide
In this article

Here’s a wince-inducing stat for you – only 14% of senior executives believe their company does a good job dealing with poor performers. The simple reason that number is so low? Performance conversations are hard. Really hard. In fact, they can be one of the most difficult parts of managing people.

They can be emotional, uncomfortable, complicated, challenging – exactly the sort of thing we naturally shy away from. Perhaps that explains why our most recent Future of Talent Report (The Six Talent Traps) found that nearly 60% of talent leaders name coaching and performance management as their single most pressing leadership capability gap.

Closing this gap begins by better understanding the reasons behind underperformance in the first place, and how to structure difficult conversations in a way that will help you handle them more confidently and effectively.

Managing an underperforming employee involves three distinct parts: first, getting to the heart of the problem, then having an honest and direct conversation, and finally agreeing a clear path forward together. What it doesn’t involve is leaving it alone until the annual review rolls around and trying to tackle it in one go.

Our Future of Talent Report also found that 62% of talent leaders believe scrapping the formal performance review process tomorrow would make no difference to productivity or would (whisper it) actually improve it. That’s a rather damning indictment of the mechanism currently in place to correct underperformance.

So, if not the annual review, then when and how can underperformance be tackled? We’re afraid to say that there’s no silver bullet for this. No one-size-fits-all solution. People are different. People are complicated. The strategy therefore can’t be a formula – but rather a set of practical tips that flex to meet the nuance of the situation.

What we can say is that managing underperformers requires regular, structured conversations, a genuine commitment to helping someone improve, and a splash of courage.

What is employee underperformance?

Everybody has a bad day. Many of us will have a bad week. Occasionally, it might not even be your year, but none of these would immediately qualify as underperforming. What marks true underperformance apart from the odd wobble here and there is when output, behaviour, or engagement have fallen measurably and consistently below the standard expected for their role.

Common causes of employee underperformance

There are many possible causes of underperformance, but a useful starting point is understanding that most issues fall into two categories – capability issues and conduct issues.

Capability issues

Capability issues happen when a team member doesn’t have the ability to perform the role required. It could be a skills or knowledge gap, or expectations that were never made clear.

Conduct issues

Conduct issues are due to motivational or commitment issues, as opposed to ability. They may not be enjoying their role or may be struggling to see their impact. It could be something going on outside work.

The two feed each other more than you’d think – nobody stays motivated for long if they’re unable to perform what’s asked of them. Similarly, a lack of motivation feeds a lack of interest in developing the skills needed to perform. As managers, when turning performance around we need to address both capability and conduct issues.

A deeper diagnostic can be achieved using MindGym’s six psychological conditions of high performance as a starting point. These are: purpose, challenge, attention, growth, recognition, and choice.

These operate at three levels (personal, team, and organisation) and underperformance is very rarely random. Rather, it’s usually a sign that one of these six is missing at whichever level the problem sits.

  • Missing Purpose (“My work matters”) – the employee can’t see how their work connects to anything meaningful. They’re going through the motions, but not sure why.
  • Missing Challenge (“It’s demanding”) – expectations are unclear, or goals feel disconnected from what they’re being asked to deliver. Worth noting, someone who isn’t stretched enough tends to quietly coast rather than visibly struggle, and coasting can look a lot like disengagement from the outside.
  • Missing Attention (“You know how I’m doing”) – they’re not getting the coaching or support they need from their manager. Feedback is either absent or not landing.
  • Missing Growth (“I’m getting better”) – no visible path forward. They’re treading water in the role and they can feel it.
  • Missing Recognition (“It’s worth the effort”) – effort and progress go unnoticed, so the incentive to keep making the effort quietly fades.
  • Missing Choice (“I can decide”) – a lack of genuine autonomy, which can look like disengagement but is often a rational response to micromanagement.

Working through this list with the employee is usually more revealing than any amount of guesswork.

For the full research behind these, and how you can apply them, download MindGym’s Reinventing Performance Management report.

How to manage an underperforming employee: 5 steps

Diagnosing the cause is only half the battle – the real work begins once you identify the problem. There mightn’t be a straightforward approach to managing underperformance, but there are some principles you can keep in mind as you navigate the conversation.

Firstly, let’s address the fact that the key part of managing underperforming employees is also the hardest – the honest conversation. As we mentioned earlier, the temptation is to bide time waiting for the “right moment” in the form of the annual review - but like most things in life (from starting a family, to buying those cowboy boots) there’s simply never the right time.

Instead, try to build the conditions for continuous performance dialogue. Regular conversations are key. Dodging the hard work of tough conversations might feel kind in the moment, but being quiet now can have loud consequences later.

So, a few principles to keep in mind (and some example questions to ask) when talking to an underperforming employee.

1. Diagnose why

Find out the reasons behind the performance. This is about asking the right questions in the right way to get to the root of the problem.

Example: “What’s changed lately that might be interfering with your work?”

2. Listen up

Pay attention and listen to what might be behind their words. When we listen properly, we hear more than just the words that are being said and this can help reveal information that will help us turn performance around.

Example: “Could you tell me more about that?”

3. Set expectations

Be clear about what’s expected of them in their role. Make sure they understand their job spec, as well as your expectations of them based on what you know they can achieve. Help them see the impact of meeting or not meeting those expectations.

Example: “I want to talk to you about this because I’d expect you to be able to file reports more accurately at your level.”

4. Focus forward

Concentrate more on the solution, as opposed to the problem. We could spend forever tracing the root of the problem, but this doesn’t always help deal with it. Switch focus to the solution as this is where most value in the conversation will emerge.

Example: “What would help to make this less of a problem for you in future?”

5. Create actions

Agree on actions for the team member to take forward. “Try and do better” won’t cut it – you need to agree on concrete, tangible actions that you can reflect on in the next conversation. If they haven’t been able to complete them successfully, perhaps you need to revise them. If they haven’t bothered to attempt them, then you know you’re dealing with a motivation issue.

A couple of practical notes to keep alongside these steps:

Document fairly and factually: Keep a shared, objective record of specific instances, feedback given, and agreed actions. This doesn’t need to be a formal process – a consistent note after each conversation is enough. It protects both parties, keeps discussions grounded in fact rather than memory, and keeps perspective if things escalate.

Check in regularly: Formally and informally. Adjust where needed, offer support, and acknowledge small wins along the way. Don’t stockpile all your attention for the final deadline – by then, you’ve missed most of the opportunities to actually help.

For a full breakdown of structuring this conversation, see how to have difficult conversations with employees.

Beyond the performance improvement plan: MindGym’s approach

You may have noticed this guide doesn’t follow the format of a formal performance improvement plan (PIP). That’s because our emphasis is on regular, structured performance conversations, which help surface and address issues early. Formal procedures still have a place, but we’ve found that ongoing dialogue is often the most effective way to support improvement.  

So, what do we focus on? Keeping the conversation going. When Coca-Cola moved from “managing” performance to actively enabling it (more below), the shift didn’t mean generating more documentation. It meant everybody talking to each other more. 

Proof it works: how Coca-Cola turned around underperformance

Every principle we’ve covered is fine in theory, but it’s worth showing how much fizz it has when put into practice. When Coca-Cola shifted from managing performance to enabling it, 28% of the employees identified as underperforming showed meaningful improvement within just 4–6 weeks.

The new approach landed well more broadly, too: 71% of managers completed structured reflection on their own practice, and 59% of associates went on to give upward feedback of their own – a sign the new culture of conversation went both ways.

Creating a structure built on continuous feedback, clear goal-setting, and genuine manager-employee dialogue resulted in 66% of associates preferring the new approach versus 14% who favoured the traditional model. One business unit saw a 31% increase in employees agreeing “I have the support I need to be successful”.

Read the full Coca-Cola case study.

How to prevent underperformance before it starts

Now, all of the above is splendid for managing underperformers - it can be extremely effective when correctly deployed. But do you know what’s even more effective? Having no underperformers to manage in the first place.

Here are a few key ideas to stop the problem before it even starts.

Set clear, challenging goals

67% of employees don’t know what’s expected of them at work, and 60% say their goals are “either irrelevant or forgotten” by the next review (5 ways to propel employee performance). That’s not an underperformance problem, it’s a clarity problem dressed up as something else. This is the 'Challenge' condition at work: ambiguity, not difficulty, is usually what kills motivation. SMART goals (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) give people something concrete to work towards. Don’t mistake clarity for micromanagement.

Invest in coaching

MindGym’s Precision Coaching methodology is grounded in behavioural science and focused on shifting specific habits and skills. This is the Growth condition in action: a mindset shift without a behaviour change is just a well-intentioned plan to do nothing differently.

Give real ownership

In MindGym’s framework of six psychological conditions, 'Choice' (genuine autonomy over one’s own work and improvement) is a core driver of sustained performance. Trust employees to turn around their underperformance with guidance, not micromanagement.

Recognise progress, not just results

76% of employees name a sense of progress on their best workdays, yet only 5% of managers recognise progress as a major motivation. It’s Purpose and Recognition working together: people need to feel their effort is seen and that it’s building toward something. Don’t wait for the finish line to send a good word their way.

Want the full research behind the six conditions and the thinking that shapes our approach? Download Reinventing Performance Management.

FAQs: managing an underperforming employee

What do you do when an employee is underperforming?

Start by understanding why, before you start planning how. Have a direct, structured conversation focused on specific behaviours (not a vague “things need to improve” chat), then agree a clear path forward together. And do it soon. Saving it for the annual review isn’t patience, it’s avoidance with a calendar date on it.

How do you deal with an underperforming employee without damaging trust?

Be honest about your intentions from the start. If it’s clear you’re there to help them succeed (not catch them out) it sets a very different tone for everything that follows. Specific, factual feedback lands better than broad criticism, and listening to their perspective before drawing conclusions goes a long way. Trust comes from honesty delivered with care, not from avoiding difficult conversations altogether.

What questions should you ask an underperforming employee?

Open, genuinely curious ones. Try: “What’s making this part of the job difficult right now?”, “What support do you need that you’re not currently getting?”, or “What would need to change for you to hit this consistently?” The goal is to understand the real picture before building any kind of plan.

How long should you give an underperforming employee to improve?

It depends on the size of the gap, but the Coca-Cola results are a useful example: meaningful improvement showed up within just 4–6 weeks when the right support was in place. Set a clear timeline with regular check-ins built in. A single high-stakes deadline at the end isn’t a plan, it’s a countdown.

Can you fire an employee for underperforming?

Yes… but only after a fair, documented process: expectations clearly communicated upfront, a genuine opportunity to improve, and an objective record throughout. Employment law varies by jurisdiction, so always loop in HR and legal counsel before going down that road.

What’s the alternative to a performance improvement plan (PIP)?

More conversation, less paperwork. MindGym doesn’t use formal PIPs. Instead, we keep the same structured, ongoing dialogue going, with a clear record of what’s been discussed and agreed. Research links weakness-focused formal reviews to performance drops of up to 27%. The process designed to fix underperformance can actively make it worse. There are better ways.

Summary: managing an underperforming employee

Managing an underperforming employee is one of the hardest things a manager has to do – and one of the most important. The good news is that the fundamentals aren’t complicated, even when the execution is: understand why performance has dipped, have the honest conversation early, and build a path forward together rather than for them.

The longer you leave it, the harder it gets – and the more it costs, in performance, in trust, and in the people who quietly walk out the door when they see low standards go unaddressed.

Start the conversation. Keep it going. That’s most of the battle.

Explore our approach to performance management.

Want to speak to our behavioural experts? Get in touch.

Back to all articles

Related Articles

Keep your head ahead.

Give your thinking a monthly workout. The latest behavioural science - turned into practical ideas - to help you lead, work and tackle everyday challenges.

Once a month. Well worth the headspace.